Cracked, loose and drummy tile repairs
Organise repairs to cracked, loose, hollow-sounding or missing tiles and failed grout in Pakenham, and find out whether the cause needs fixing first.
Illustrative image, not a completed customer project.
A cracked or loose tile is often a symptom of something underneath. The cause may be movement in the slab, a poor bond, water getting behind the tiles or simple impact damage. Replacing a tile without understanding the cause can mean the new one fails the same way. Ask for the cause to be assessed before the repair is quoted.
Send a tile repair enquiry with photos, the room and what you have noticed. It goes to up to three independent local businesses, which decide whether they can help and contact you directly. We are a referral service and do not inspect or repair tiles.
Common tile problems
| What you see or hear | Possible causes to ask about |
|---|---|
| One cracked tile | Impact from a dropped object, a void under the tile, or a crack in the base |
| A line of cracked tiles | A crack or joint in the slab running underneath |
| Hollow or “drummy” sound when tapped | Tile not fully bonded to the base |
| Tiles lifting or tenting | Movement with no room to expand, or bond failure |
| Loose wall tiles | Failed adhesive, damaged sheeting, or water behind the tiles |
| Crumbling or missing grout | Wear, movement, or water getting through |
| Dark staining around tiles | Water penetrating from a leak or failed waterproofing |
These are general patterns, not a diagnosis. The business that inspects the tiles should explain what it thinks the cause is and why.
Drummy tiles
A tile that sounds hollow when tapped is not fully stuck to the surface below. Some hollowness at corners can be minor, but large hollow areas can lead to cracking or lifting. Drummy tiles can come from poor adhesive coverage during laying, movement in the base, or water breaking down the bond.
Ask the business:
- How many tiles sound hollow, and where?
- Is the area getting larger?
- Does it need repair now, or monitoring?
- If tiles are lifted, what will be checked underneath?
Tapping tiles to map hollow areas is a common check. If a whole floor sounds drummy, the issue may be larger than a few tiles.
Tiles lifting or tenting
When tiles rise up in a ridge, called tenting, it is often because the tiled area had nowhere to move. Large tiled floors usually need movement joints at walls and at intervals across the floor, filled with a flexible sealant rather than grout. If movement joints were left out or grouted over, the tiles can push against each other as the building and slab move with temperature.
Tenting tiles can lift suddenly and crack. Keep people away from the area and ask a business to assess it. Our tile failure guide explains how to describe and record what you see.
Cracks from the slab
A crack running through a line of tiles often follows a crack or joint in the concrete underneath. Replacing the tiles alone may not stop it coming back. A business may recommend a crack isolation membrane, a movement joint at that point, or investigation of the slab by a builder or engineer if the crack is large or growing.
If your home is under a builder’s warranty, check with the builder before arranging repairs to cracking that may come from the slab.
Wet area tiles
In showers, bathrooms and laundries, cracked tiles or failed grout can let water reach the waterproofing and the structure behind. Loose wall tiles in a shower are a warning sign that water may already be behind them. Stains on nearby walls, skirting or floors, swelling of vanity bases or door frames, and musty smells can also point to a leak.
Do not seal over a suspected leak with silicone or a grout sealer and hope it stops. Ask for the cause to be assessed. Our shower leak assessment page covers investigation, and our wet area waterproofing page covers the system behind the tiles.
Matching replacement tiles
Finding a matching tile is the hardest part of many repairs. Tile ranges are discontinued, and new batches can differ in colour even within the same range.
Options include:
- Using spare tiles kept from the original job.
- Finding the same range through tile suppliers.
- Taking a tile from a hidden area, such as under a vanity or inside a cupboard, and replacing that with a close match.
- Using a deliberate contrasting tile as a feature.
- Retiling a whole area, such as a full floor or a full wall.
Ask the business which options it suggests and what the result is likely to look like. If you have spare tiles, keep them with the box label showing the range and batch.
Regrouting
Grout that is cracked, crumbling or stained can sometimes be removed and replaced without lifting tiles. Regrouting can improve appearance and help keep water out of joints, but it does not fix failed waterproofing underneath. Ask whether regrouting suits your situation and what grout type the business proposes.
Silicone or flexible sealant joints at internal corners, around baths and where tiles meet other materials wear out over time. Replacing these is a common maintenance task.
Matching grout colour
New grout rarely matches old grout exactly, because old grout has aged and absorbed dirt. For a small repair, the new grout may stand out. Some owners regrout a whole wall or floor to get an even colour. Ask the business what result to expect.
Movement joints and sealant
Movement joints are gaps filled with a flexible sealant rather than grout. They sit at internal corners, where walls meet floors, around the edges of large tiled floors, over structural joints in the slab and at intervals across big areas. They let the tiled surface move slightly without cracking.
Many tile repairs trace back to missing or failed movement joints. Signs include cracked grout in internal corners, a crack along the edge of a floor, or tiles lifting near a wall. When a business repairs these areas, ask whether it will add or renew movement joints, and what sealant it will use. Grout in an internal corner of a shower often cracks for this reason, and replacing it with grout again rarely lasts.
How a single tile is replaced
Replacing one tile without damaging its neighbours takes care. The general process is:
- Remove the grout around the tile.
- Break and remove the damaged tile carefully, working from the centre.
- Clean off the old adhesive so the new tile sits level.
- Check the base under the tile for cracks, voids or moisture.
- Lay the replacement tile with suitable adhesive.
- Regrout, and reseal if the tile is in a wet area or is natural stone.
In a shower, step 4 is important. Removing a tile can damage the waterproofing beneath. Ask the business how it will protect or repair the membrane under a wet area tile. If the membrane is damaged, a small tile repair can turn into a larger job.
Natural stone repairs
Natural stone tiles can chip, crack, stain and etch. Some damage can be honed or polished out, while deep cracks may need the tile replaced. Matching natural stone is harder than matching porcelain because each piece is different. Stone often needs resealing after repair. Ask whether the business works with natural stone and what result to expect.
Outdoor tile repairs
Outdoor tiles can crack or come loose from movement, water getting under them, tree roots, or the base settling. Before replacing outdoor tiles, ask what caused the failure. Water pooling on the surface, poor falls, or a cracked slab underneath need fixing for a repair to last. Our outdoor tiling page covers outdoor work.
Safety around damaged tiles
Broken tiles have sharp edges. Lifting tiles can be a trip hazard. Keep children and pets away from damaged areas, and cover sharp edges with tape or a mat until the repair. If tiles have come loose from a wall, check that others above or near them are not about to fall.
Repair or retile?
Sometimes repairing a few tiles makes sense. Sometimes the cause is widespread and retiling the whole area is the better choice. Ask the business to explain its reasoning.
| Situation | Often considered |
|---|---|
| A few tiles cracked by impact, good bond elsewhere | Replace individual tiles |
| Hollow tiles scattered over a large area | Investigate bond; may need wider retiling |
| Tenting floor | Lift affected area, add movement joints |
| Loose tiles in a shower | Investigate leak and waterproofing first |
| No matching tiles available | Feature repair or retile the area |
If retiling is recommended, see our tile removal and preparation page.
What to send with your enquiry
Use the enquiry form and include:
- The room and location of the damaged tiles.
- Photos showing the damaged area and the wider room.
- When you first noticed the problem and whether it is getting worse.
- Any leaks, stains or smells nearby.
- The age of the tiling, if known.
- Whether you have spare tiles.
Yes Right Pty Ltd runs this referral website and may be paid a fee by businesses it introduces. It does not inspect or repair tiles. The business you choose confirms the cause, repair method and price directly with you. See also our floor and wall tiling page and tiling in Pakenham.